Noir's Reviews

I cannot describe how awful this manga is beginning to end, especially the end. There’s so much wrong with it. After reading manga for over 18 years and reading some terrible stuff this is somehow in my top ten worst mangas I’ve ever read. However, it’s drama and it’s captivating. You feel bad for the FL and antagonist, you understand why they are the way they are. You feel angry and sad and so many emotions for everyone. That’s probably why it’s in my top ten worst. It was full of cliche tropes but also not. I’m literally sitting here with my husband mad at him for no reason and also screaming at him explaining what happened. It’s good. It’s so awfully good. If you want some fudged up stuff read it.

Drawings were nice, but this didn’t feel like a complete story but a start to one. The small amount of issues they hit were addressed but felt hollow. Not a bad read. Not a good read.

Everyone will find someone who loves them how they are, some will find out that not everyone fits that mold and get hurt by that but you have to move on and forward with hope. ❤️

We love side characters that keep stuff going bc irl sometimes people can’t even see what they have. Communication was non existent and it was cliche but was a good fun ride.

Such a wholesome and absolutely dirty manga at the same time. It’s adorable and has no conflicts. Just two happy people in love with each other physically and emotionally .

Feel like this should have at least 4 more chapters! Awkward people in an awkward situation relationship is always so cute and funny. Wish we met more characters and feels like just the beginning of a series. Sad. Especially since the way the island is set up is hilarious.

This story was a messy situation tied up in a bow. I liked the ending and found it funny. Watching someone struggle with such a huge change in their life is difficult. It was fun watching her with each man and how easy it is to watch your life unfold like that. Hope I never go through the situation. Four stars because it was full of tropes and was predictable while not being super interesting but was still a fun “revenge”esque story.

This story is hilarious, I laughed hard at least once in every chapter. Every single character is dorky, imperfect and lovable. The story isn’t completely uploaded and I can’t wait to finish. The drawing is, kind of wonky the first few chapters but it definitely has its own style and leans into it in later chapters. It does have some cliches but it’s also worked in well.

I love the sass and complete story. It’s hard to find on the site stories that make having premium worth it, but this is one of them. Would’ve loved for it to be twice as long to get to know more characters. Very cute otherwise.

This is a nice story that feels like a dream situation of people making mistakes and owning up to them. Life may not go as you want and how you think you’ll deal with a situation isn’t so simple. I’d probably give it a 4.5 if I had an option but I do like that it’s not so cut throat nor ends in a perfect way.

What a bitter sweet story. It’s not heavily influenced by romance but there are moments which is nice. It really felt like I was watching someone start their journey into adulthood. The story didn’t just focus on the MC which was nice. Definitely recommend!

Been a while since I cried, didn’t expect it to be over something so short or simple. It’s just so cute. I love it.

This was a good story about the realities of modern dating and looking for marriage especially from a female point. No one is perfect and that’s nice. No big revenge plots just the ups and downs of life and failure. Wish it was longer so we could see two of the group final story but was still a great read.

Fluff, a little drama, good world building and interesting characters. Most things are settled more amicably and efficiently than normal but I like that. Can’t wait to continue reading.

This is one the first stories I’ve read with this type of plot line. It’s so funny and dumb but still interesting and detailed. You can see how the plot will go because it’s still filled with basic tropes, however still very entertaining. Love it.

So happy to be reading stories that are actually good. Worth the read. I love the story and that it doesn’t go exactly as expected.

Nice quick read. Villains and support characters feel primarily one dimensional but not a bad thing. Fun, simple and adorable.

This series could be 100% extended through SEVERAL more books with a little more details in between each year gap and I would read all 100+ chapters with an extra story the dives into the future. Nothing special story was, but it had funny moments and felt complete. I’ve been reading a lot of shorter “complete” stories and most don’t feel like a good complete story even if still entertaining. This is an exception.

Such a cute adorable story. This felt like warm potato soup, simple but makes your stomach feel good and full. I like the way the story progresses and ends without getting TOO serious or falling TOO hard into tropes. Adorable and worth the read. Also made me hungry.